[
  {
    "id": "solid_o2_ceiling_in_normalized_tables",
    "text": "In the PSI experimental tables we normalized, no solid-fuel test has a recorded oxygen level above 22.2%. Of 263 solid-fuel tests (BASS, BASS-II, Saffire-I to -III), 140 record oxygen in their table, between 13.6% and 22.2%. In PSI's documents the highest oxygen documented for a solid is 22.7% (BASS as-run test 54, cabin reading of the day). Both are limits of the PSI material, not of NASA's testing.",
    "scope": "tests_normalized.csv, rows with fuel_phase = \"solid\" and row_kind = \"test\" (the BASS table also holds one non-test row, 'SOOT Cleaning'). Oxygen is recorded in the table for BASS-II (129 rows), Saffire-I (2) and Saffire-II (9); the PSI tables for BASS (121 tests) and Saffire-III (2) carry no oxygen column. The 22.7% value is an AI-extracted value (provenance extraido_ia) from the BASS as-run test matrix workbook; it is the ISS cabin reading of that day, not a measurement next to the sample. BASS also ran N2-diluted tests in 2013 (15.9-17.8% O2). Smoke rows (SAME, SAME-R) are excluded.",
    "values": {
      "solidRows": 264,
      "solidTests": 263,
      "solidRowsWithO2": 140,
      "minO2Percent": 13.6,
      "maxO2Percent": 22.2,
      "maxO2PercentDocumented": 22.7,
      "maxO2PercentDocumentedProvenance": "extraido_ia"
    },
    "verifiedOn": "2026-11-14",
    "sources": [
      {
        "title": "PSI-25 BASS-II experimental table (NASA Physical Sciences Informatics)",
        "url": "https://psi.nasa.gov",
        "locator": "files/PSI-25/Experimental table; column \"Calibrated initial O2 % by vol\""
      },
      {
        "title": "PSI-98 and PSI-99 Saffire-I and Saffire-II experimental tables",
        "url": "https://psi.nasa.gov",
        "locator": "column \"Percent O2\""
      },
      {
        "title": "PSI-26 BASS as-run test matrix (NASA Physical Sciences Informatics)",
        "url": "https://psi.nasa.gov/physci/repo/data/investigations/PSI-26",
        "locator": "PSI-26/Science Documents/PSI-26_Science Documents_As Run_Test Matrix.xlsx, sheet \"as run matrix\", cell AA58 (column \"O2 % by volume\", group \"ISS environment\"); see web/public/atlas/extracted/test_conditions.csv"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "id": "solids_tested_above_ceiling_outside_psi",
    "text": "NASA has burned solids in microgravity at higher oxygen and reduced pressure outside the data we hold. Saffire-V burned cotton and PMMA at 25.4-26.2% O2 and 70.7-72.6 kPa (about 10.3-10.5 psia); Saffire-VI burned cotton/fiberglass fabric and PMMA at 28.8-31.0% O2 and 54.1-55.2 kPa (about 7.8-8.0 psia). Saffire-IV ran at 22.0% O2 and 100 kPa. A Nomex sample on Saffire-VI did not ignite.",
    "scope": "Large-scale (about 40 cm wide) samples in 20 cm/s forced flow aboard uncrewed Cygnus vehicles, as reported in conference papers. A later paper rounds the same tests to oxygen mole fractions of 0.22-0.31. These results are not in tests_normalized.csv.",
    "values": {
      "saffireIV": {
        "o2Percent": [
          22.0
        ],
        "pressureKPa": [
          100.0
        ]
      },
      "saffireV": {
        "o2Percent": [
          25.4,
          26.2
        ],
        "pressureKPa": [
          70.7,
          72.6
        ]
      },
      "saffireVI": {
        "o2Percent": [
          28.8,
          31.0
        ],
        "pressureKPa": [
          54.1,
          55.2
        ]
      }
    },
    "verifiedOn": "2026-11-14",
    "sources": [
      {
        "title": "Urban et al., Fire Safety Implications of Preliminary Results from Saffire IV and V Experiments on Large Scale Spacecraft Fires, ICES-2021-266",
        "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20210011521",
        "locator": "Table 1"
      },
      {
        "title": "Urban et al., Preliminary Results from the Saffire VI Experiment, ICES-2024-365",
        "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20240002981",
        "locator": "Table 1; Section II (Nomex sample did not ignite)"
      },
      {
        "title": "Urban et al., Heat and Smoke Emission from Tests on the Saffire VI Experiment, ICES-2026-577",
        "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20260001992",
        "locator": "Table 1"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "id": "psi_saffire_coverage",
    "text": "The PSI repository lists Saffire-I, -II and -III (PSI-98, PSI-99, PSI-100). Saffire-IV, -V and -VI were not among the 133 investigations PSI returned on 2026-11-14.",
    "scope": "PSI investigation search API queried on 2026-11-14 (133 investigations, 24 under Combustion Science). PSI adds investigations over time, so this must be re-checked before it is repeated.",
    "values": {
      "psiInvestigations": 133,
      "combustionInvestigations": 24,
      "combustionFlight": 19,
      "combustionGround": 5
    },
    "verifiedOn": "2026-11-14",
    "sources": [
      {
        "title": "NASA PSI investigation search API",
        "url": "https://psi.nasa.gov/geode-py/ws/repo/search?source=psi&type=investigation&from=0&size=500",
        "locator": "fields Accession, Acronym, Research Area, Project Type"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "id": "lunar_window_counts",
    "text": "With the strict threshold (O2 at least 30% and pressure at most 10.2 psi = 0.694 atm), our normalized PSI tables hold 66 measured tests, all gas flames: ACME CFI-G (48) and ACME Flame Design (18). None is a solid or a liquid. Widening the pressure limit to 0.72 atm (10.6 psi) adds 17 FLEX droplet tests run at a nominal 0.7 atm (recorded 0.703-0.714 atm) with 30% or 34% O2, for 83.",
    "scope": "tests_normalized.csv, row_kind = \"test\", rows with both oxygen and pressure recorded in the PSI table. Of the 66, 46 are inverse flames (28 ACME CFI-G, 18 ACME Flame Design) whose oxygen is the burner stream, not an ambient atmosphere; 20 (all ACME CFI-G) have that oxygen in the ambient. Excluded: 8 FLEX-2 design-matrix rows (30% O2, 0.5 atm; planned, not confirmed runs) and 23 ACME BRE test-day rows with O2 of 30% or more but no pressure in the table. Tests documented only in PSI documents (extracted layer) are not part of these counts. 1 atm = 14.696 psi.",
    "values": {
      "strict": {
        "minO2Percent": 30,
        "maxPressurePsi": 10.2,
        "maxPressureAtm": 0.6941,
        "measuredTests": 66,
        "byInvestigation": {
          "ACME CFI-G": 48,
          "ACME Flame Design": 18
        },
        "byFuelPhase": {
          "gas": 66,
          "liquid droplet": 0,
          "solid": 0
        },
        "inverseFlames": 46,
        "ambientOxygenTests": 20
      },
      "withTolerance": {
        "minO2Percent": 30,
        "maxPressureAtm": 0.72,
        "maxPressurePsi": 10.58,
        "measuredTests": 83,
        "byInvestigation": {
          "ACME CFI-G": 48,
          "ACME Flame Design": 18,
          "FLEX": 17
        },
        "byFuelPhase": {
          "gas": 66,
          "liquid droplet": 17,
          "solid": 0
        }
      },
      "excludedDesignMatrixRows": 8,
      "excludedRowsWithoutPressure": 23
    },
    "verifiedOn": "2026-11-14",
    "sources": [
      {
        "title": "tests_normalized.csv (this project, generated by scripts/atlas/normalize.py from PSI experimental tables)",
        "url": "/atlas/tests_normalized.csv",
        "locator": "columns o2_frac, pressure_atm, row_kind"
      },
      {
        "title": "PSI-159 ACME CFI-G, PSI-10 ACME Flame Design, PSI-69 FLEX experimental tables",
        "url": "https://psi.nasa.gov",
        "locator": "see source_file and source_row of each row"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "id": "partial_gravity_not_bounded",
    "text": "Microgravity and 1 g results do not safely bound lunar or Martian gravity. NASA drop-tower, aircraft and centrifuge tests show that some materials burn at lower oxygen concentrations near lunar gravity than at 1 g, because buoyant flow there is strong enough to feed the flame but too weak to blow it off. The effect is material-dependent: some high-temperature materials did not show it at lunar gravity.",
    "scope": "Published ground-based partial-gravity tests (seconds to tens of seconds; thin fuels and small rods). The challenge statement says micro- and normal-gravity results \"could bound\" intermediate gravity; the published evidence contradicts that for flammability limits. No long-duration lunar-surface data exist yet.",
    "verifiedOn": "2026-11-14",
    "sources": [
      {
        "title": "Sacksteder and T'ien, Buoyant downward diffusion flame spread and extinction in partial-gravity accelerations, Symp. (Int.) Combust. 25 (1994) 1685-1692",
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/S0082-0784(06)80816-7",
        "locator": "bibliographic record only; findings read in the AIAA 93-0828 abstract (NTRS 19930040901)"
      },
      {
        "title": "Ferkul and Olson, Zero-Gravity Centrifuge Used for the Evaluation of Material Flammability in Lunar Gravity, J. Thermophys. Heat Transfer 25(3) (2011) 457-461",
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.2514/1.T3651",
        "locator": "bibliographic record only; findings as summarized in ICES-2025-392"
      },
      {
        "title": "Urban et al., Solid Fuel Ignition Testing for Lunar Applications, Theory and Experimental Results, ICES-2025-392",
        "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20250002114",
        "locator": "Abstract; Introduction; Conclusion"
      },
      {
        "title": "Ferkul, Kralik and Liao, Material Flammability at Lunar and Martian Gravity, 57th LPSC (2026)",
        "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20260000646",
        "locator": "Introduction; Current Knowledge"
      },
      {
        "title": "Olson and Ferkul, Evaluating Material Flammability in Microgravity and Martian Gravity Compared to the NASA Standard Normal Gravity Test, AIAA 2012-3492",
        "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20130010991",
        "locator": "Abstract"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "id": "gravity_scope_of_our_data",
    "text": "Every row in our normalized table comes from a flight experiment on the ISS or a Cygnus vehicle, so every row is microgravity. The gravity value is assumed from the platform; PSI's tables have no gravity column. The table contains no partial-gravity and no 1 g rows. PSI also holds five ground or analysis investigations; opened on 15-nov-2026, none holds a table of 1 g tests (two hold only metadata, two hold simulations, one holds digitized figure data of 1 g counterflow flames without oxygen, pressure or flow per point), and the Saffire-II table lists 1 g results next to its samples without their test conditions. NASA states that PSI currently has no partial-gravity combustion data.",
    "scope": "tests_normalized.csv (gravity_source = \"assumed_from_platform\" on all 2,157 rows; the gravity_g column for a measured gravity is empty). The statement about PSI as a whole rests on the challenge text and on PSI's investigation list (5 of 24 combustion investigations are ground investigations), not on our table.",
    "values": {
      "rows": 2157,
      "gravitySource": "assumed_from_platform",
      "psiCombustionGroundInvestigations": [
        "PSI-60",
        "PSI-62",
        "PSI-115",
        "PSI-117",
        "PSI-142"
      ],
      "rowsWithMeasuredGravity": 0
    },
    "verifiedOn": "2026-11-15",
    "sources": [
      {
        "title": "NASA Space Apps Challenge 2026, Flame in Freefall",
        "url": "https://www.spaceappschallenge.org/2026/challenges/flame-in-freefall/",
        "locator": "Potential Considerations, \"Partial-gravity data\": \"there is currently no partial-gravity combustion data available in PSI\""
      },
      {
        "title": "NASA PSI investigation search API",
        "url": "https://psi.nasa.gov/geode-py/ws/repo/search?source=psi&type=investigation&from=0&size=500",
        "locator": "field Project Type"
      },
      {
        "title": "This project, web/public/atlas/ground_investigations.json (what the five ground investigations and the Saffire-II 1-g columns hold)",
        "url": null,
        "locator": "groundInvestigations; oneGComparisonsInFlightTables"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "id": "row_kinds",
    "text": "The 2,157 rows are not 2,157 tests: 1,385 are individual tests, 469 are SPICE data points (454 of them belong to 133 ignitions that can be identified by their ignition time; for 15 the ignition cannot be established), 43 are ACME BRE test days expanded by oxygen level, 82 are test days of ACME CLD Flame, ACME E-FIELD Flames, ACME s-Flame and SLICE (one row per day, not per test), 168 are planned or nominal condition grids (FLEX-2 and SAME), 9 are exact repetitions of another row (8 in the CFI table, 1 test day in the E-FIELD table), and 1 (BASS 'SOOT Cleaning') is not a test.",
    "scope": "tests_normalized.csv, columns row_kind and test_group. ACME BRE: the PSI table has 18 test days and reports 194 flames ignited; it lists the oxygen levels used each day (21, 25, 26.5, 34, 40%) and states that chamber pressure varied but is not given. CFI: the PSI table has 87 rows and 79 distinct tests. SPICE: each table row is one recorded fuel/air setting of a flame; rows are grouped by GMT day and ignition time. Grouping by ignition is this project's choice, confirmed by the project owner on 15 Nov 2026: the SPICE final report (p20) counts '526 flames ... ignited and studied', which is the row count of the investigators' workbook (469 table rows plus 57 rows of day 62, absent from the PSI table). The table gives 135 distinct ignition times; ten pairs of them, on the same day, are 1 or 2 s apart. Owner decision of 15 Nov 2026: a pair is one ignition when the investigators' workbook gives both of its blocks the same test number, which happens in two pairs, both on day 45 (17:20:46 and 17:20:47, 'No.' 9 in cells H22 and H23; 17:29:48 and 17:29:49, 'No.' 12 in cells H28 and H29; sheet 'Data record of Video and Stills' of 'Spice Flight Test Data II modified.xls'), so 135 times give 133 ignitions. The other eight pairs stay separate: one block has a 'No.' and the other none, and no source says they are one ignition (merging all ten would give 125; evidence pair by pair in datos/psi/spice_encendidos_cercanos.csv). Day 62 follows the same rule in the extracted layer: 22 ignitions. Test-day tables: ACME CLD Flame 32 days and 344 flames, ACME E-FIELD Flames 20 days and 219 flames (its last day is repeated in the PSI table), ACME s-Flame 18 days and 276 flames, SLICE 12 days (no flame count); appended after the other rows so that no earlier row moves.",
    "values": {
      "rows": 2157,
      "test": 1385,
      "test_day_expanded": 43,
      "test_day": 82,
      "testDayTables": {
        "PSI-21": {
          "rows": 32,
          "flamesIgnited": 344
        },
        "PSI-22": {
          "rows": 20,
          "flamesIgnited": 219,
          "duplicateRows": 1
        },
        "PSI-23": {
          "rows": 18,
          "flamesIgnited": 276
        },
        "PSI-106": {
          "rows": 12,
          "flamesIgnited": null
        }
      },
      "design_matrix": 168,
      "acmeBre": {
        "testDays": 18,
        "flamesIgnited": 194,
        "expandedRows": 43
      },
      "duplicate_row": 9,
      "not_a_test": 1,
      "cfi": {
        "tableRows": 87,
        "distinctTests": 79
      },
      "spice": {
        "rows": 469,
        "ignitionsEstablished": 133,
        "distinctIgnitionTimes": 135,
        "rowsInEstablishedIgnitions": 454,
        "rowsWithoutEstablishedIgnition": 15,
        "flamesPerFinalReport": 526,
        "ignitionPairsOneOrTwoSecondsApart": 10,
        "ignitionPairsMergedSameWorkbookNo": 2,
        "ignitionPairsOneOrTwoSecondsApartNotMerged": 8,
        "ignitionsIfThosePairsWereMerged": 125,
        "day62RowsInWorkbook": 57,
        "day62IgnitionsInExtractedLayer": 22
      },
      "data_point": 469
    },
    "verifiedOn": "2026-11-15",
    "sources": [
      {
        "title": "PSI-20 ACME BRE experimental table",
        "url": "https://psi.nasa.gov",
        "locator": "columns \"Oxygen Conc (percent)\", \"Flames Ignited\", \"Notes\""
      },
      {
        "title": "scripts/atlas/normalize.py (this project)",
        "url": "/atlas/tests_normalized.csv",
        "locator": "module docstring; function row_kind"
      },
      {
        "title": "PSI-21, PSI-22, PSI-23 and PSI-106 experimental tables; ACME CLD Flame, E-FIELD Flames and s-Flame final reports (Table 1)",
        "url": "https://psi.nasa.gov",
        "locator": "columns \"Test Day\", \"Flames ignited\"; errata in /atlas/errata.json"
      },
      {
        "title": "SPICE investigators' workbook, PSI-107/Raw Data/Reduced Gravity/SPICE Day 045/PSI-107_Raw Data_Spice Flight Test Data II modified.xls",
        "url": "https://psi.nasa.gov",
        "locator": "sheet \"Data record of Video and Stills\", column H \"No.\": H22 = H23 = 9 (ignitions 17:20:46 and 17:20:47), H28 = H29 = 12 (17:29:49 and 17:29:48); every pair in datos/psi/spice_encendidos_cercanos.csv"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "id": "exploration_atmospheres",
    "text": "NASA's current planning atmospheres for lunar and Martian surface missions are 8.2 psia with 34% O2 and 10.2 psia with 26.5% O2. The 8.2/34 point replaced an 8.0 psia / 32% recommendation from 2006. These are design points and recommendations, not final requirements for every vehicle, and oxygen could reach 36-40% once control bands are included.",
    "scope": "NASA technical reports from 2010 to 2026. The challenge statement's \"30% or greater ... 10.2 psi or less\" is consistent with the 8.2/34 point; the 10.2/26.5 point falls below its oxygen bound.",
    "values": {
      "designPoints": [
        {
          "pressurePsi": 8.2,
          "o2Percent": 34
        },
        {
          "pressurePsi": 10.2,
          "o2Percent": 26.5
        }
      ],
      "superseded": [
        {
          "pressurePsi": 8.0,
          "o2Percent": 32
        }
      ]
    },
    "verifiedOn": "2026-11-14",
    "sources": [
      {
        "title": "Abney et al., Impacts of Reduced Pressure Atmospheres on ECLSS Architectures, NASA/TM-20260003925 (NESC-RP-20-01610), 2026",
        "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20260003925",
        "locator": "Sections 5.0, 6.2, 7.1.3.2"
      },
      {
        "title": "NASA Exploration Atmospheres Working Group, NASA/TP-2010-216134",
        "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/henninger-8.2-34-atm-tp216134-2010.pdf",
        "locator": "Executive Summary; Table 10"
      },
      {
        "title": "Norcross et al., Evidence Report: Risk of Hypobaric Hypoxia from the Exploration Atmosphere, JSC-CN-34806, 2015",
        "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20150021491",
        "locator": "Introduction (2006 recommendations; 2012 revision to 8.2 psia / 34%)"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "id": "high_o2_flammability_data_are_1g",
    "text": "NASA reports that it has limited material flammability data above 30% O2, that essentially all existing flammability data for flight materials come from 1 g testing, and that minimal data exist at varying oxygen levels in partial gravity.",
    "scope": "NASA Engineering and Safety Center assessment of ISS life-support hardware for exploration atmospheres (2026), findings F-12 and O-4.",
    "verifiedOn": "2026-11-14",
    "sources": [
      {
        "title": "Abney et al., Impacts of Reduced Pressure Atmospheres on ECLSS Architectures, NASA/TM-20260003925 (NESC-RP-20-01610), 2026",
        "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20260003925",
        "locator": "Section 7.1.3.2; Finding F-12; Observation O-4"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "id": "microgravity_lowers_o2_limit",
    "text": "BASS-II found that some materials burn in microgravity, with slow forced airflow, at lower oxygen than in normal gravity: PMMA rods burned down to 13.6% O2, about 1-2 percentage points below their 1 g limits. Passing NASA's 1 g screening test does not guarantee a material will not burn in space.",
    "scope": "BASS-II tests in the ISS Microgravity Science Glovebox, 21% down to about 14% O2 by nitrogen dilution. PMMA and cotton/fiberglass samples.",
    "values": {
      "minO2PercentTested": 13.6
    },
    "verifiedOn": "2026-11-14",
    "sources": [
      {
        "title": "Olson and Ferkul, Microgravity Flammability of PMMA Rods in Concurrent Flow, 9th U.S. National Combustion Meeting, 2015",
        "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20150008961",
        "locator": "Abstract; Experiment description; Figure 4 discussion"
      },
      {
        "title": "Olson et al., Flammability Limits from BASS-II Testing in Microgravity Compared to Normal Gravity Limits, ICES-2019",
        "url": "https://hdl.handle.net/2346/84505",
        "locator": "Abstract; discussion of PMMA limits (1 g: 17% downward, 15.4% upward; microgravity 1-2% lower). Read as search-engine excerpts, not the full PDF."
      },
      {
        "title": "NASA, A Researcher's Guide to: Combustion Science, NP-2015-10-034-JSC",
        "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/np-2015-10-034-jsc_combustion_in_reduced_gravity-iss-mini-book-011116-508.pdf",
        "locator": "section on low-stretch flames: \"NASA-STD-6001 Test 1 is not conservative\""
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "id": "rockets_and_propellants_scope",
    "text": "The challenge marks its list of habitable crew environments (spacecraft, space stations, lunar and Martian surface bases and pressurized rovers) with an asterisk, and the footnote says that fire safety involving rockets and propellants is generally beyond the scope of the research available in the PSI database, because the high velocities in rocket engines make that combustion effectively independent of gravity. It is a statement about what PSI's research covers, not a rule that excludes rockets from the challenge.",
    "scope": "The asterisk follows \"pressurized rovers.*\" in the first objective (Details tab, OBJECTIVES); the footnote is the paragraph that starts with \"*\" after the Earth-applications paragraph of the same section. It is the only asterisk on the page. Read with a real browser on 2026-11-15; an earlier saved copy of the page had dropped the footnote.",
    "values": {
      "asteriskAfter": "pressurized rovers.*",
      "quote": "*Fire safety involving rockets and propellants is generally beyond the scope of the research available in the PSI database. The high velocities within rocket engines render the combustion effectively independent of gravity — although a rocket’s launch is of course strongly dependent on gravity.",
      "section": "Details > OBJECTIVES, footnote"
    },
    "verifiedOn": "2026-11-15",
    "sources": [
      {
        "title": "NASA Space Apps Challenge 2026, \"Flame in Freefall: SI-Powered Fire Safety Insights from Microgravity Combustion Data\"",
        "url": "https://www.spaceappschallenge.org/2026/challenges/flame-in-freefall/",
        "locator": "Details tab, OBJECTIVES, footnote to the asterisk of the first objective; text saved in datos/web/instantaneas/challenge_flame_in_freefall_details.txt and docs/reto/enunciado-flame-in-freefall.md",
        "quote": "*Fire safety involving rockets and propellants is generally beyond the scope of the research available in the PSI database. The high velocities within rocket engines render the combustion effectively independent of gravity — although a rocket’s launch is of course strongly dependent on gravity.",
        "snapshot": "datos/web/instantaneas/challenge_flame_in_freefall_details.txt"
      }
    ]
  }
]
